Envisioning the Energy Future was an event held from 10 am to 4 pm on Tuesday, February 24, 2015 at the conference center of the Federal Reserve Bank across from South Station in Boston. The conference was hosted by the Acadia Center, formerly ENE, Energy Northeast and brought together practitioners from Denmark and all over NE to share their expertise.
The morning panel was on "Utility in the future," moderated by Abigail Anthony, Acadia Center
Nathan Adams, Green Mountain Power
Tim Woolf, Synapse Energy Economics, Inc
Jonathan Schrag, Guarini Center (NY)
Peter Rothstein, New England Clean Energy Council
Jonathan Schrag - will distributed generation be as green as RGGI? Market-based initiatives are driving the marketplace. They are looking at things like Priceline for an open marketplace structure, at least in NY. Brooklyn doing an innovative demand management project.
Current state microgrid projects can drive grid and regulatory modernization. Focus on what you want the grid to do rather than particular technologies.
Peter Rothstein - more than 10% of the largest cleantech companies in the world in MA, over 80,000 soon to be 100,000 people employed in the state in this sector. More than 10% of ARPA-E grants in MA, many in storage. How do you get utilities to invest in new technologies, in an environment where they now spend .2% on R & D, about a tenth of what industry in general spends. RD&D - demonstrations to develop workable business models. Third parties are going to be a major party to future developments. Change the model to one more like telecom which anticipates the customers' next needs. The innovations will need to serve both customers and provide value for the grid.
Tim Woolf - it may be harder to get the regulators to change than the utilities. Performance based rate making - UK's RIO (sp?) is one example and require strict performance standards. Demonstrates a shift to outcomes. Performance based mechanisms are a way to proceed - track and report, target setting, rewards and penalties. Each of these measures can stand alone or combined. There are pitfalls in terms of uncertainty of outcomes and unintended consequences as well as gaming and manipulation. Collecting data is a no regrets policy that can be implemented now.
Nathan Adams - changing grid model, customer value, use local resources. Moving to a network leveraging distributed marginal pricing. Most people don't want to deal with real time pricing but technology can do it for them. Third parties to create value for utility, customers, and the third parties. NY, CA, MA are now leading in policy reform. Pilot microgrid project in Rutland to build the model - frequency regulation, solar ramp smoothing , islanding with automation to follow by Fall after summer installation. Storage through a solar/battery - battery 4MW - 2.5 MW solar. Over 200 controllable water heaters. Hardest challenge is to engage customer appliances without inconveniencing customers. Change the utility capital model - cap revenue to drive efficiency; turn grid into platform business so that the market creates prices not regulators. Frequency regulation market ISO-NE is initiating is a good step forward.
Over lunch, Klaus Veslov, of Oestkraft (http://oestkraft.dk), the municipal utility on the Danish island of Bornholm spoke about "The Ecogrid EU Project in a Strategic Perspective" (http://ecogridbornholm.dk)
Danish is wind first with solar and biomass and a full electrification of infrastructure, exchanging energy with Sweden, Norway, and UK (UK connecting with Iceland). Storage is a problem and they can't make a business case for hydrogen on any terms. Danish political and social consensus is going to renewables quickly.
Bornholm - bright green island, 100% fossil free by 2025, as a business case. 80% renewables now with a lot of problems with solar intermittence balanced by coal and diesel. Population is 45,000 and has become the national test site for new energy systems with municipalities, companies, and universities participating. 2000 households in the Ecogrid, about 4000 people, with lots of green building, energy efficiency, geothermal, and electric vehicles. From consumers to prosumers. First stage from 2011-2015 with a proposal for Ecogrid 2.0. Now there is overproduction of wind. Household investments in air to water heat pumps with district heating. Reversing market system for peak shaving and educating customers to use energy when it is being produced, running demand backward - grid demands energy from distributed resources. Participants are not being motivated by money because there isn't much economic benefit yet. Automating about 1200 households with energy controls. 2 hours of training per participant at their demonstration Villa Smart house but voluntary demand response lasts for only about 30 days.
Leveling the Playing Field for Distributed Energy Resources
Scudder Parker, VT Energy Investment Corp
Amy Boyd, Acadia Center
Fran Cummings, Peregrine Energy
Jim Grevatt, Energy Futures Group
Kerrick Johnson, VELCO
Amy Boyd - skyrocketing transmission costs in NE, higher than the rest of the US. Define reliability needs rather than transmission needs to bring non-wire alternatives into the picture earlier. Regional entities don't pay for non-wires, the states pay for it on their own.
Jim Grevatt - NY case study for ConEd on energy efficiency as an alternative to transmission and distribution costs. They realized they did not have to build the projects that were deferred through efficiency. 2013 heat wave spurred them to greater action. Brooklyn Queens project is $200 (?) million, 85% residential.
Fran Cummings - RI National Grid on solar PV as a distributed resource in Tiverton and Little Compton. Found that orienting solar to the west rather than due south for more value to the grid in peak shaving and distribution. Solar is a better distribution resource than expected.
Pecan Street project in Austin, TX - a neighborhood energy initiative.
Kerrick Johnson - VT case study, a transmission company, 2010-2013 deferred $400 million transmission through alternatives. Only 4% of that benefit was to VT ratepayers as opposed to regional ratepayers. Transmission returns on a state by state level can benefit the state's ratepayers to the detriment of regional ratepayers.
NB: IBM came up often in terms of data and controls both here and on Denmark. Energy smart cities are halfway to smart cities.
The Role of Energy Efficiency and Demand Side Resources to Reduce Price Pressures in the Energy System
James Howland, Acadia Center
Jeremy Newberger, national Grid
Jeff Schlegel, Schlegel and Associates
Michael Stoddard, Efficiency Maine Trust
Eric Wilkinson, ISO-NE
Jeff Schlegel - Energy efficiency as demand reduction, lowering price volatility but the multiple values of the efficiencies are disaggregated based upon the regulations and pricing. Adjust peak times closer to reality, now 11am to 3pm. No longer any winter peak capacity numbers in ISO-NE.
The morning panel was on "Utility in the future," moderated by Abigail Anthony, Acadia Center
Nathan Adams, Green Mountain Power
Tim Woolf, Synapse Energy Economics, Inc
Jonathan Schrag, Guarini Center (NY)
Peter Rothstein, New England Clean Energy Council
Jonathan Schrag - will distributed generation be as green as RGGI? Market-based initiatives are driving the marketplace. They are looking at things like Priceline for an open marketplace structure, at least in NY. Brooklyn doing an innovative demand management project.
Current state microgrid projects can drive grid and regulatory modernization. Focus on what you want the grid to do rather than particular technologies.
Peter Rothstein - more than 10% of the largest cleantech companies in the world in MA, over 80,000 soon to be 100,000 people employed in the state in this sector. More than 10% of ARPA-E grants in MA, many in storage. How do you get utilities to invest in new technologies, in an environment where they now spend .2% on R & D, about a tenth of what industry in general spends. RD&D - demonstrations to develop workable business models. Third parties are going to be a major party to future developments. Change the model to one more like telecom which anticipates the customers' next needs. The innovations will need to serve both customers and provide value for the grid.
Tim Woolf - it may be harder to get the regulators to change than the utilities. Performance based rate making - UK's RIO (sp?) is one example and require strict performance standards. Demonstrates a shift to outcomes. Performance based mechanisms are a way to proceed - track and report, target setting, rewards and penalties. Each of these measures can stand alone or combined. There are pitfalls in terms of uncertainty of outcomes and unintended consequences as well as gaming and manipulation. Collecting data is a no regrets policy that can be implemented now.
Nathan Adams - changing grid model, customer value, use local resources. Moving to a network leveraging distributed marginal pricing. Most people don't want to deal with real time pricing but technology can do it for them. Third parties to create value for utility, customers, and the third parties. NY, CA, MA are now leading in policy reform. Pilot microgrid project in Rutland to build the model - frequency regulation, solar ramp smoothing , islanding with automation to follow by Fall after summer installation. Storage through a solar/battery - battery 4MW - 2.5 MW solar. Over 200 controllable water heaters. Hardest challenge is to engage customer appliances without inconveniencing customers. Change the utility capital model - cap revenue to drive efficiency; turn grid into platform business so that the market creates prices not regulators. Frequency regulation market ISO-NE is initiating is a good step forward.
Over lunch, Klaus Veslov, of Oestkraft (http://oestkraft.dk), the municipal utility on the Danish island of Bornholm spoke about "The Ecogrid EU Project in a Strategic Perspective" (http://ecogridbornholm.dk)
Danish is wind first with solar and biomass and a full electrification of infrastructure, exchanging energy with Sweden, Norway, and UK (UK connecting with Iceland). Storage is a problem and they can't make a business case for hydrogen on any terms. Danish political and social consensus is going to renewables quickly.
Bornholm - bright green island, 100% fossil free by 2025, as a business case. 80% renewables now with a lot of problems with solar intermittence balanced by coal and diesel. Population is 45,000 and has become the national test site for new energy systems with municipalities, companies, and universities participating. 2000 households in the Ecogrid, about 4000 people, with lots of green building, energy efficiency, geothermal, and electric vehicles. From consumers to prosumers. First stage from 2011-2015 with a proposal for Ecogrid 2.0. Now there is overproduction of wind. Household investments in air to water heat pumps with district heating. Reversing market system for peak shaving and educating customers to use energy when it is being produced, running demand backward - grid demands energy from distributed resources. Participants are not being motivated by money because there isn't much economic benefit yet. Automating about 1200 households with energy controls. 2 hours of training per participant at their demonstration Villa Smart house but voluntary demand response lasts for only about 30 days.
Leveling the Playing Field for Distributed Energy Resources
Scudder Parker, VT Energy Investment Corp
Amy Boyd, Acadia Center
Fran Cummings, Peregrine Energy
Jim Grevatt, Energy Futures Group
Kerrick Johnson, VELCO
Amy Boyd - skyrocketing transmission costs in NE, higher than the rest of the US. Define reliability needs rather than transmission needs to bring non-wire alternatives into the picture earlier. Regional entities don't pay for non-wires, the states pay for it on their own.
Jim Grevatt - NY case study for ConEd on energy efficiency as an alternative to transmission and distribution costs. They realized they did not have to build the projects that were deferred through efficiency. 2013 heat wave spurred them to greater action. Brooklyn Queens project is $200 (?) million, 85% residential.
Fran Cummings - RI National Grid on solar PV as a distributed resource in Tiverton and Little Compton. Found that orienting solar to the west rather than due south for more value to the grid in peak shaving and distribution. Solar is a better distribution resource than expected.
Pecan Street project in Austin, TX - a neighborhood energy initiative.
Kerrick Johnson - VT case study, a transmission company, 2010-2013 deferred $400 million transmission through alternatives. Only 4% of that benefit was to VT ratepayers as opposed to regional ratepayers. Transmission returns on a state by state level can benefit the state's ratepayers to the detriment of regional ratepayers.
NB: IBM came up often in terms of data and controls both here and on Denmark. Energy smart cities are halfway to smart cities.
The Role of Energy Efficiency and Demand Side Resources to Reduce Price Pressures in the Energy System
James Howland, Acadia Center
Jeremy Newberger, national Grid
Jeff Schlegel, Schlegel and Associates
Michael Stoddard, Efficiency Maine Trust
Eric Wilkinson, ISO-NE
Jeff Schlegel - Energy efficiency as demand reduction, lowering price volatility but the multiple values of the efficiencies are disaggregated based upon the regulations and pricing. Adjust peak times closer to reality, now 11am to 3pm. No longer any winter peak capacity numbers in ISO-NE.
NB: Different peaks for different flows: peak demand, peak solar and renewables supply, peak system efficiency
Eric Wilkinson - the vast majority of energy efficiency has been in lighting. ISO-NE wants to see new interconnection standards so that a blip in transmission does not result in taking a large chunk of PV offline due to automatic shutdown.
Jeremy Newberger - RI has an energy efficiency focus.
Michael Stoddard - ME energy efficiency through Efficiency Maine Trust statewide, about 2.7 cents per kWh (?) to save energy. Boothbay project replaced about $16 million of transmission with $6 million of non transmission resources within six months. Boothbay is using some of the fishery industry freezers as energy storage.
Even MA, most efficient in the US for the last 5 years, lags in terms of energy efficiency compared to Europe.
Eric Wilkinson - the vast majority of energy efficiency has been in lighting. ISO-NE wants to see new interconnection standards so that a blip in transmission does not result in taking a large chunk of PV offline due to automatic shutdown.
Jeremy Newberger - RI has an energy efficiency focus.
Michael Stoddard - ME energy efficiency through Efficiency Maine Trust statewide, about 2.7 cents per kWh (?) to save energy. Boothbay project replaced about $16 million of transmission with $6 million of non transmission resources within six months. Boothbay is using some of the fishery industry freezers as energy storage.
Even MA, most efficient in the US for the last 5 years, lags in terms of energy efficiency compared to Europe.
The slides are available at http://acadiacenter.org/document/envisioning-our-energy-future-forum/
No comments:
Post a Comment